Sunday, 28 September 2014

PAUL SCHOLES V STEVEN GERRARD

This post is going to be for the most complete central midfielder the english game has EVER seen. Jamie Carragher and the rest of the scoucers in there dreamworld believe Gerrard is better than the ginger ninja.

Lets get one thing straight, Paul Scholes is the best English midfielder to play the game, period, end of story! Only him does the great Zidane describe as the "best player of his generation" or Pirlo "as the only one world class English player." Nobody else has successfully adapted their game in the way Scholes did from scoring goals at one end, to completely controlling games at the age of 35. Who could forget the performance in the derby where as fergie put it "he passed City to death" and then scored the winning goal in stoppage time.

His levels of anticipation, vision, awareness, control, movement, creating angles, all of these words roll off the tongue because he simply was the greatest. Gerrard had (I use past tense because we all saw the world cup) great leadership qualities and was a scorer of great goals, but when it comes to game understanding, controlling a game and frankly just being an overall better player, there is only one winner.This type of player does not follow the conventional Football Manager break down of qualities to make a star. Players such as Xavi, Pirlo, Kroos, and Xabi Alonso, are not the qucikest, they cant dribble, not the fittest, cant tackle, But they are judged by a higher power, game understanding, and ability to control games, they play the game with their brain and execute quicker than any other player on the field. 

It is not a tangible asset. You cannot teach a young player to perform at that level. These players have a gift. 

Its the same reason why Messi has won 4 Ballon d'ors and is generally regarded as greater than our hero Ronaldo. Ronaldo is a machine that has all the individual abilities any player could ask for, but watching Messi is ls like watching an artist who was born with something not from this world.

My defining memory of Scholes is not him scoring from 30 yards against Barcelona, or even his goal against City. It is the old Arsenal clashes when he was up against the brute force of Patrick Vieira. Vieira was the best box to box midfielder in the world at the time and he would steam towards Scholes hoping to intimidate the little fella, guess what son, the ball has been passed around you before you can even get near me. Gerrard will never EVER get close to that level of football artistry and it's showing this season now players are putting him under pressure in the defensive midfielder position.

The swing of Scholes' right boot as he switches play with pinpoint accuracy will be forever missed at Old Trafford. What other player could retire, make his come back without any training in the Manchester derby with some boots he grabbed from JD Sports, and then boss the game? The answer is only Paul Scholes.

I only wish he had been more media savvy to get the recognition he deserved. His time with England would certainly have been enhanced had this been the case. Sven Goran Erickson recently described him as the most "complete midfielder he has worked with" which is the best way to sum up this great player.

If you disagree with any of my opinions or even if you agree, please drop me a comment.

@HallowedTurfBlg

No comments:

Post a Comment